Sam’s Club Gas for Members Only

I stopped for gas at Sam’s Club the other night and noticed a sign on the pump saying that, as of February 1st, gas sales will be limited to members only. Thus far anyone has been able to buy, but Club members have received a $0.05/gallon discount. I’m curious to see what (if anything) this will end up doing to their prices. When they first started selling gas at our local Sam’s, it was a pretty good deal… The ‘list price’ was the same as all of the local stations, so we really were getting a nickel off per gallon. Their base price has, however, floated upward over time, such that we’re now only saving a penny or two per gallon relative to ‘typical’ prices in our area. This hasn’t been a problem, though, as our local Kroger has since opened a gas station. Not only do they have low prices, but we also get a $0.10/gallon discount for every $100 worth of groceries that we buy. Needless to say, we buy most of our gas there. Still, it sure would be nice if Sam’s Club would couple their move to members only gas with more aggressive pricing. I doubt it’ll happen, but a guy can hope, can’t he?

14 Responses to “Sam’s Club Gas for Members Only”

  1. why does sams club in beavercreek charge a dollar when you use your freedom card beings they don’t take cash. I bought gas the other day and saved a whole 55 cents then paid a dollar to use my card. BIG SAVINGS ! I will be buying gas elsewhere.

  2. Anonymous

    We are getting ready to go on vaction and when my husband retired He received quite a few credit cards for Sams Club gas. We want to use them when we travel, but it would be nice to know when we need gas where the next station will be. Do you have a listing of all Sams Club gas statons?

  3. Anonymous

    Our Sams club(Boston) doesn’t do gas but our Stop and Shop does. They do 5 cents off if you have a S+S card and another 5 cents if you bought $50 in groceries. I’m not positive, it might be 10 cents. In calculating the price of their food I don’t think it is a great deal since you end up spending more on less food.

  4. Anonymous

    I can echo Todd’s point about where gas stations make the most money, on the convenience store. Costco’s just doing the exact same thing… except they have a WAREHOUSE. 🙂

    I rely on Costco to suppress the prices of gas stations around it so I can take advantage of the extra 5% cashback using a card Costco won’t take at the pump.

  5. Anonymous

    Generally speaking, gas stations don’t usually make a lot of money from the gasoline sales. They often have to sell it at a loss of a cent or two per gallon in order to stay competitive with others in the area.

    They make money from people buying candy bars and extra services. So it really makes a lot of sense that Costco would make the gas ‘members only’ as the members are the ones who buy the junk inside so they can afford the pumps.

  6. mbhunter: That’s one thing that I forgot to mention… While Sam’s Club doesn’t take credit cards inside the store, they do take them at the pump. So I can still cash in on those juicy 5% credit card rewards for gas purchases.

  7. Anonymous

    FWIW, Sam’s Club here has always required membership in order to buy gas. But then again, I’ve always been able to get a much better deal by driving across the state line. (The _closest_ I’ve seen prices get between the two states is 30c/gal. 50c/gal is not uncommon and 75c/gal is not unheard-of. I might pay city prices if I drove enough that I had to refill on weekdays, but I don’t, so I don’t.)

    I do miss the Speedway 2c/gal discount for rewards members, though. 🙂

  8. Anonymous

    Our Costco doesn’t take credit cards at their pumps. I find that I can do better with my gas rebate card at a nearby gas station. With gas prices as they are, I save a dime a gallon with the 3% rebate.

  9. Anonymous

    My local BJ’s has a member price that is on par or a few cents more/less than the best in the area, which is generally about 10-30 cents less than anywhere else in town (I know where to get the cheapest gas).

    One of the gas stations that tends to be cheap doesn’t get my business anymore, though, even though they are on my way to/from work; bad service I can understand, but not from an owner/manager.

    BJ’s non-member price tends to be 20-30 cents more expensive than the stations right nearby.

  10. Anonymous

    Our local Costco sells gas to members only and the price is about $.10 lower than the BP station in front of the store (I’m sure BP didn’t really appreciate Costco’s choice of location.)

    With any luck, your Sam’s club will follow suit.

Leave a Reply